The three-month long Shafia trial has ended with guilty verdicts for three Shafia family members. However, it has left the Muslim community’s and the South Asian community’s image tarnished in the eyes of the broader Canadian society.
The Shafia case has also left the community to rethink its values and belief system. While it has initiated the debate within community members, what is sad is that many community-based organizations do not want to comment publically on whether the Shafia case is a story based on honour killings, domestic violence or just one of the cases in which the darker side of human beings is displayed in the most vulgar way.
What has been good on the surface, at least, is that 34 imams from across North America gathered in Mississauga to issue a fatwa condemning honour killings, domestic violence and misogyny as “un-Islamic.”
Imam Syed Soharwardy, in no uncertain terms, declared on Saturday that “…If anybody is thinking that honour killing is allowed in Islam, or domestic violence is okay or misogyny is okay, we are saying no, you are dead wrong.”
Regardless of what religious authorities are saying, the organizations Generation Next contacted for a comment called for deeper introspection within our homes and communities.
We were told that cases of domestic violence are quite common in the neighbourhoods of Thorncliffe, Don Valley West and Region of Peel. Instances of husband beating up wife, father unhappy with his daughter’s dress sense and subsequent calls to the police are not uncommon.
The community has diagnosed the problem to be the “mindset” that leads to a particular style of raising males in South Asia and in South Asian community of Canada. The “mindset” to control by a “slap” or a “stick.” The urge to dominate the household needs to change for preventing the deaths of young girls who are caught in the two worlds and are uncertain of how to navigate between these worlds.
Many members of the community believe that instead of religious institutions such as mosques, the need is to have community centres where cultural, social and religious activities go hand in hand. Most importantly, community and religious leaders need to be scholars and academicians, rather than typical maulvies who have been teaching in South Asia at the tip of the stick and promote little more than rote-learning of the Holy Scripture and prayers.
The immigrant generation from South Asia has been taught that marriage is a compromise, whereas in the Western world, it’s mutual understanding between partners. In a typical South Asian marital arrangement, women end up making all the compromises and men tend to dominate.
Perhaps the worst impact of marital disputes is on kids as Child Services and other such organizations get involved. Custody battles ensue, and men’s egos in the process are even more bruised, which lead them to act in stubborn and egoistic ways.
The role of law enforcement is also crucial. Are police trained with the knowledge if what constitutes honour killings, or what shapes abuses take in South Asian households? How do the police respond to an anonymous phone call of domestic abuse? Can women take charges back against their men and what kind of counseling is available before kids are handed over to foster parents?
We asked a few community organizations to give us their feedback.
Here’s what they had to say:
Rabia Khedr, Federation of Muslim Women Spokeswoman and Board Member
“There is no place for any forms of violence in our society. The Shafia murder trial is a very “sick” and tragic example of gendered violence plaguing Canadian families. The motivation, details and complexities of this type of violence are beyond our imagination and cannot be rationalized by any labels. As a society and a community, we must refrain from engaging in a discourse of over-categorization that distracts us from the real issue. As Canadian women, we must speak-out in one united voice to fight against all forms of violence and focus our efforts and resources to build structures and safeguards that would prevent and eradicate this form of violence. As Canadians we must remember all the victims of gender violence, namely: Aqsa Parvez, the Shafias, the 14 young students in Montreal, our missing Aboriginal sisters and many other women who are victims of the same fate, but never make it into the media spotlight. As women in our communities, we must work proactively with schools, police, community and religious organizations to educate and demand that gender violence be taken seriously so that such situations are recognized early and culturally responsive interventions are put in place before it is too late.”
Mazhar Shafiq, Chairman of CAPO
“First of all honour killing/domestic abuse is highlighted in the media when it happens in the Muslim Community. Even though it has nothing to do with the religion. This is more of a cultural thing rather than a religious thing. There are many cases in Sikh, Hindus and other communities as well where honour killing cases were found but media did not highlight those cases.
“Secondly, as an immigrant who comes from a different culture, with different mindset, there is a lot of work need to be done. Mosques have a bigger role to play, but they are only limited to religious education. They should educate youth how to become a good Canadian while keeping their own values.
“Government also needs to play an important role. Police need to be trained about different cultures and their sensitivities. There needs to be a community council comprised of police, representative from religious institutes (Mosque, Temple etc.) and community leaders who should intervene at very initial stage when there are signs of domestic violence.
“The parents need to understand how important it is to spend time with their kids. The problem is that both father and mother start running after money. They both work and don’t have time to see what kids are doing. If the parents spend time with their kids and also keep an eye on their activities from the early age, these things will never happen.
“Also there is a need for fathers to change their behavior according to the situation of a new country. They cannot control their kids as they were used to in back home. In Canada, they need to be a friend of their kids. That is the only way they can keep their kids on right track.”
Baldev Mutta, CEO of Punjabi Community Health Services
“I think as a community we should look at violence against women very seriously. Religions may not sanction killing of a human being, but cultural practices dictate otherwise. In the South Asian community, the appalling apathy is frightening. Very few religious leaders, political leaders, and self-styled leaders have come forward to denounce these horrendous murders. No cultural practice justifies these killings. It is about time that men along with women, who espouse dignity and sanctity of human stand up to the cultural practices and boycott those families where such practices might be rampant.
“One of the drawbacks in the social services is that many organizations are not skilled in making an assessment about whether a woman is in danger of “honour killing”. The social workers are not trained and neither do any “clinical tools” exist. I think it is about time that the government invests some funds in preventing these sorts of tragedies. The same holds true for “law enforcement” agencies. My personal opinion is that it would be difficult for a police officer to determine if a woman’s life is in danger. For example, we know that woman can be protected if some is stalking them. But would a police officer protect woman if there is a danger of “honour killing”? No such law exists. I think we need to step up our pressure on politicians as to why they are so silent.”
Mayada Sharef, Therapist and Cross-Cultural Educator
“As for the Shafia case, I feel very saddened for the victims and the rest of the children. I think that all parents have to grow a lot and be open to change and adapt as their children grow and change.
“Parenting is not a static formula that you can apply across age groups, genders, cultures and individual differences. It’s something that has to be very responsive and in its responsiveness it guides you to the direction you have to take in order to meet the needs of each of your children…For the Shafia family, my guess is that many elements influenced their choices negatively…One of the important elements is the structure of the family and the way the adults of this family lived (too busy with many things other than parenting). Also, the transition in the children’s lives and the shift from the East to the West happened during the critical teen years for the older sisters, so they’ve been changing fast at many levels, (while parents were busy with other issues probably), until they reached the inevitable clashes between generations as well as cultures…What I cannot really sympathize with is the decision to get rid of the victims (and the problems) instead of accepting the challenge and trying to work your way through it as any good parent…”